When someone is charged with a crime, the case may either be resolved through a plea bargain or proceed to trial. While many criminal cases are settled before reaching the courtroom, others move forward to trial due to several complex and strategic factors. Understanding what makes a criminal case go to trial instead of settling can provide clarity for defendants facing serious legal decisions.
1. Strength of the Evidence
One of the main reasons a case goes to trial is the perceived weakness of the prosecution’s evidence. If the defense believes that the evidence against the defendant is insufficient or unreliable, they may choose to challenge it in court. For example, questionable eyewitness testimony or improperly obtained evidence can lead defense attorneys to recommend a trial over a plea deal.
2. Innocence of the Defendant
Defendants who strongly maintain their innocence are often less willing to accept a plea deal, especially if it requires admitting guilt. They may prefer to have their day in court, hoping to be acquitted by a judge or jury. In such cases, going to trial may be seen as the only way to clear their name.
3. Harshness of the Plea Deal
Sometimes the plea offer presented by the prosecution is simply too harsh. If a deal includes a lengthy prison sentence, lifetime consequences, or other significant penalties, the defense might feel there is little to lose by going to trial. In some situations, a trial might result in a better outcome, even if there’s some risk involved.
4. Legal or Constitutional Issues
Criminal defense attorneys may push for a trial when there are legal or constitutional issues that could affect the outcome of the case. For instance, if there are violations of the defendant’s rights, such as illegal search and seizure, a trial might provide the opportunity to suppress key evidence and secure a dismissal.
5. Strategic Considerations
Experienced defense lawyers sometimes advise going to trial based on strategic considerations. If they believe the prosecution has overcharged the case or that the jury might be sympathetic to the defendant, they may recommend proceeding to trial to seek a more favorable verdict.
6. Client’s Personal Goals
Every client is different. Some want to avoid jail at all costs; others prioritize clearing their name. A defendant’s personal goals, values, and circumstances will heavily influence the decision to accept a plea or go to trial. A good attorney will explain the risks and benefits of each option, helping the client make an informed choice.
Facing Criminal Charges? Let a Skilled Attorney Defend Your Rights
If you or a loved one is facing criminal charges, the decision to go to trial is one of the most critical you’ll make. At Manderscheid Law Firm, PLLC, our experienced criminal defense attorneys will analyze every detail of your case, explain your legal options, and fight for the best possible outcome—whether through strategic negotiation or aggressive trial defense.
Contact us today for a free consultation and let us protect your future.
This post was written by a professional at The Manderscheid Law Firm, PLLC. The Manderscheid Law Firm, PLLC, is your trusted criminal case lawyer Clearwater FL. With a commitment to integrity, advocacy, and understanding, my firm stands out in its dedication to giving each client and their case the personal attention they deserve. Whether you’re facing charges for DUI in St Pete FL, drug offenses, theft, or any other criminal matter, you can trust our experienced team to fight for your rights and provide the best possible defense. At Manderscheid Law Firm, PLLC, we believe in a tailored approach, ensuring every client feels heard and supported throughout the legal process.
